On The Boards For Bryn Mawr: Dunkin' Donuts To Bank.

SaveArdmoreCoalition's picture

Bryn Mawr lost Dunkin' Donuts at the end of 2007. Currently under discussion is converting the existing structure to a bank. Please read the following excerpt from Lower Merion Township's memo on the concept which was recently presented for discussion at the January 8th Planning Commission Meeting:
Dunkin Donust bryn mawr

SUBJECT: PRELIMINARY LAND DEVELOPMENT PLAN, 733 W. Lancaster Avenue, Bryn Mawr SD# 3603, Ward 4.
Proposal
The applicant, Citizens Bank, is seeking comments on the proposal to:
• Construct two additions totaling 658 square foot addition to the existing Dunkin’ Donuts building;
• Construct a drive-through lane with two points-of-service;
• Reconfigure the parking lot, including the removal of thirteen (13) parking spaces; and
• Waiver of Tentative Sketch Plan requirements.

Dunkin Donust bryn mawrRear of Dunkin Donuts

The proposal is illustrated on the accompanying set of plans that includes five (5) sheets, prepared by Nave Newell, Inc. dated October 25, 2007, last revised December 20, 2007....The County recognized that the proposed plan meets the current C-2 zoning requirements but does not meet the Bryn Mawr village zoning the Township has been discussing. The County noted that the proposal is not pedestrian friendly, in that the building is located more than fifty (50’) feet from the sidewalk and caters to vehicular traffic with the drive-through lanes. The County suggests that the applicant provide additional landscaping along the right-of-way to make the streetscape more pedestrian friendly.

Dunkin Donust bryn mawrFront/Side of Dunkin Donuts

The County also noted that the two driveways accessing Lancaster Avenue are unsafe and strongly suggested that the driveway closest to Town Place be removed altogether or, at a minimum be angled in order to discourage east-bound traffic from turning left into the property. The County also noted that vehicular traffic entering the site at this point may come into conflict with handicap drivers backing out of designated handicap parking spaces....When this project first appeared before the Land Development Committee, it was suggested that the applicant investigate ways of making the building more pedestrian friendly and reduce the potential for vehicular conflicts. Staff suggested that the applicant investigate demolishing the existing building and construct a new building closer to the street. In response, the applicant stated that the terms of the lease are based on renovating the existing site.

This post is informative and the opinions are just that, opinions. It is not a condemnation per se of the project, only the prospect raises serious questions:

1. How many banks do we need? How many retail branches of the same brand do we need? What is the actual need in the community since so many folks bank online or patronize a physical bank branch occasionally?

2. Banks are static businesses, what else could go in a site like this in a perfect world?

3. This proposed bank branch is in a severely congested area: at Town Place across from the former Barnes and Noble site, soon to be a "Walgreens"

4. There is another bank in a former fast food site (former Boston Chicken/Roy Rogers) across Town Place. Bank of America is going into the old Storehouse Silo site a block and a half to the east, and when you go to the center of town, in addition to Bryn Mawr Trust's gorgeous Main Branch, there are several smaller banking institutions.

5. Our area and township have a LOT of the following types of businesses: nail salons, fast food, banks, hair salons, car dealerships. Not to do anyone out of business who wants to do business in our great township, but how many do we need versus the definite need for other types of retail - we need more diversity, don't we?

6. Why would this property owner (whom we believe also may own buildings in Ardmore on Ardmore Ave at Lancaster) be resistant to a bank wishing to invest enough capital to demolish a ugly building with no architectural or historical value and replace it with a new structure with new systems placed more appropriately on the lot footprint?

7. How will this bank be able to satisfy all the concerns over traffic, pedestrian safety, pedestrian friendly, etc if it merely tacks an addition onto this existing structure?

8. How will 2 drive thru lanes work with the exisiting building and lot configurements OR a new building and lot configuration?

9. The bank in question has a branch at Woodside Road and Lancaster Avenue. Please, go drive by it. Also take a long look at another bank with an awkward lot in a problematic location: Commerce Bank in Haverford at Lancaster Avenue and Haverford Station Road.

10. Does everyone have a comfort level with this project considering all of the initial concerns, of having a waiver of tentative sketch?

11. How would this building fit with the vision for the future of Bryn Mawr? Please refer to http://www.lowermerion.org/ecdev/brynmawrstudy.html

12. Have any of you out there ever run into traffic issues with the neighboring stores and their lot? You know, Staples or even the crazy traffic at Starbucks across Lancaster?

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
JohnN's picture

I think it is totally absurd to locate a bank at this location. Traffic will be difficult at best, pedestrians will suffer also. There are about 6 banks in 1/2 mile and 4 within a few hundred feet. Meanwhile, if you are a Dunkin fan (guilty) you must travel to Paoli or to Ardmore.
It is almost as absurd as the CVS/Eckerd/Walgreens situation. It is fascinating to observe the phenomena eg how we go through waves of similar businesses.
Town Planning appears to be just an exercise in giving the appearance of doing something!

dmuth's picture

You know what would be a neat way of bringing this problem to people's attentions?

Google Maps lets users create custom maps. We should look into creating a series of Google Maps for the website that list all car dealerships, banks, luxury condos, etc. in the area. That would help show the distribution of different kinds of businesses.

We could also mark the proposals of new kinds of businesses in relating to existing businesses.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.